Detailed close-up of a tabby cat's face showcasing its expressive eyes and fur texture. The cat looks unamused with your disrespectful microcopy

A few months back, I started noticing a trend in the microcopy on pop-up notifications. These pop-ups—often asking me to do something like review an app, turn on notifications, or sign up for a newsletter—have two buttons. One is the call-to-action, and the other is usually labelled Not Now:

Notification from Mint that reads: "Enjoying Mint? Tap a star to rate it on the App Store." There are two buttons on bottom: 5 stars for rating the app and one that reads "Not Now"
I don’t think I’ve ever rated an app from one of these notifications (also, RIP Mint)
Notification that reads: " Flixter. Fantastic! We would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know what you love about the new Flixter app. Thanks!" There are two buttons on bottom labeled "Send Feedback" and "Not Now"
Spoiler: I didn’t give Flixter my feedback.
Fullscreen in-app notification that reads "DON'T MISS OUT. Get notified about your friend requests, comments, likes and more." There are two buttons on bottom labeled "Allow Notifications" and "Not Now"
Dear Nike Training Club, I don’t want your notifications.
Fullscreen in-app notification that reads "Chris, your advice can make all the difference. LinkedIn recognizes you as an expert in your field. Give back by being part of the career advice community." There are two buttons on bottom labeled "Show me how" and "Not now"
Thanks but no thanks, LinkedIn.
A website notification that reads " Strengthen your profile. Let's update your headline to match your current position. That way, people can easily find and connect with you. There are two buttons on bottom labeled "Not now" and "Update headline"
Of course, LinkedIn is on here twice.

Alternatively, the button may use one of Not Now’s close cousins, Later or Maybe Later:

An iOS notification that reads "Stay informed with IMDb notifications. Get notified about the latest trailers, movies, awards & events, and more. There are two buttons labeled "Later" and "Update now"
I don’t want your spam now, IMDb. I also don’t want it later.
A pop-up notification that reads "You're all set!" There are two buttons on bottom labeled "Next: Invite friends" and "Maybe later"
No, I won’t want to invite friends to a Meetup group they don’t care about later. You probably just want my contact data anyway.
Fullscreen in-app notification that reads "Travel Offers. Sometimes Amtrak sends customers notifications from this app about special offers and opportunities. Would you like to receive these offers?" There are two buttons on bottom labeled "Send Me Offers" and "Maybe Later"
I don’t want your inbox clutter, Amtrak. I won’t change my mind later.

Now, there’s nothing wrong with having a Not Now or Maybe Later button, and there’s even a good argument for including one as an option. If users are in a hurry to complete some task in your app, they won’t have time to say, update the app your right now, but they might have time later.

The problem is the omission of a button to opt out of future notifications. Excluding this option takes control away from users. The only choices are submit to the will of the app or be asked to submit again later. And subjecting users to the same pop-up over and over is disrespectful of their time.

A more honest label instead of Not Now or Maybe Later might be:

“I have zero interest in reviewing your app, turning on your notifications, granting you access to my personal data, or signing up for your newsletter, but please, feel free to nag me about it from now until the end of time.”

But I guess that doesn’t fit on a button.

A better way

A Tweet from @erniemiller at 8:55 AM on November 10, 2017 that reads "Dear @reddit: please add a 'never' button. I don't like to lead you on with a 'maybe later,' because it's never gonna happen." The Tweet includes a screenshot of a notification from the Reddit app that reads "Enable nofitications to stay updated about your posts and comments."
A great suggestion for Reddit from a real-life user

A better alternative is to include an opt-out button. Some apps already do this with options like Never, Never ask again, or Don’t ask again:

A banner notifications that reads "We strongly recommend enabling desktop notifications if you'll be using Slack on this computer." There are three options: "Enable notifications", "Ask me next time", and "Never ask again on this computer"
I actually usually turn Slack notifications on, but it’s great they have an option not to be pestered again if I didn’t want them.
A notifications from LastPass that reads "Welcome to your vault! Your vault is a safe place to store passwords, notes, profiles for online shopping, and even documents. And no matter where you work, your vault keeps everything in sync, so you can stay organized and save time." There are three options: "Show me around", "Later", and "Never"
LastPass let me permanently skip their onboarding tour, which was smart considering I had used it on multiple devices over several years by this point.
An in-app notification that reads "SATY IN THE KNOW WITH FANDANGO. Get alerts to new movie releases, special offers and free screenings." There are three options: "Get Push Notifications", "Not Now", and "Dont' Ask Again"
Fandango let me tell them I’ll never want their junk mail.

You’ll notice that those examples still have Not Now options. You don’t have to get rid of that option if you think users might actually want to opt in at a later time. Just realize there are some people you’re never going to reach:

A Tweet by @PaulClark_ at 3:40 PM on August 15, 2017 that reads "Have been hitting the 'ASK ME LATER' butoon on my iPad for the best part of 2 years now instead of just doing a 10 minute update ."
Why get up, when we can just keep hitting the Snooze button?

What do you think about this trend? Does it irritate you as much as it does me? Do you have other examples of interfaces that take choice and control away from users?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest Posts